The Beanball: A Scourge In Baseball | Draft Day Suit

The Beanball: A Scourge In Baseball

Nothing infuriates me more during a baseball game than a beanball. Ok, ok, maybe bunting. I’ve never understood why so many fans cheer for a bean. It’s not the sportsmanlike behavior fans expect of the men that we pay a lot of money to watch play a game we love. These men are paid quite handsomely and are idols to many in their communities, and then in an instant they can turn to this childish attempt at “revenge”. What happened to being the bigger man? What happened to playing the game with grace? What happened to ethics?

Matt LaPorta falls to the ground after being hit by a bean during a game between Team USA and China during the 2008 Summer Olympics.

Matt LaPorta falls to the ground after being hit by a bean during a game between Team USA and China during the 2008 Summer Olympics.

The bean has been happening in baseball nearly as long as the game has been played in our country. For those unfamiliar with the term, a beanball is a pitch thrown at a batter’s head. Some definitions include the word intentionally, some don’t. I don’t think it much matters. Whether the pitch is intentional or not, it can cause serious damage, one bean even killed a player, Ray Chapman of the Cleveland Indians back in 1920. Nowadays a death is much less likely to happen, given the use of helmets and advances in medicine, but injuries caused by the bean happen every single season, with some doing enough harm to end careers.

Probably one of the most popular stories surrounding the bean is that of Adam Greenberg and the 2005 Cubs. In his first MLB plate appearance, and on the first pitch he received, he was struck in the back of the head by a pitch from Valerio de los Santos. Greenberg was taken out of the game and placed on the DL for the rest of the season. He has spoken in many interviews about the concussion he suffered and the various residual effects he has had to deal with including headaches and vertigo. He spent most of the next seven years playing on various minor league teams, with varying levels of success all while dealing with the side effects of his injury. In 2012 he was given a one-day contract to play with the Marlins through the PR efforts of a Cubs fan and an online petition. He struck out during his only plate appearance in the game.

Adam Greenberg holds his head after being hit by a pitch in 2005.

Adam Greenberg holds his head after being hit by a pitch in 2005.

Most people I know are, like me, outraged by the bean and think it has no place in baseball. Unfortunately a few weeks ago, I watched as people I know and respect “asked” their teams pitcher to throw a bean. They wanted him to exact revenge against one of the other teams players for what they suspected was an intentional beaning of one of our players the inning before. I don’t know if that bean was intentional or not, but I was horrified that they would want one of our pitchers to then do the same to one of the opposing teams players. I understand being upset that one of your favorite players was hurt, but does that mean we should go out and do the same to the other team? Some say yes: an eye for an eye.

I think a better “punishment” for a bean is stronger discipline from the league. Immediate game ejections are standard now along with 4-8 game suspensions and fines. For most pitchers, a 4-8 game suspension doesn’t do much to punish them, honestly. Major league teams have so much depth on their pitching rosters that being suspended for a few games merely pushes them back in the rotation or perhaps causes them to miss one game. I think suspensions should take into account position, in this case, a 20 game suspension would “hurt” a pitcher and their team a lot more than a 6 game suspension, for example. That, to me, is a real punishment, and the only way to perhaps curb these ridiculous beanball fueled feuds.

I’d like to see the bean banned in baseball, but I’m sure that is a very unlikely thing to happen. So, as far as I can see, the next best approach to ridding the league of this scourge is to make it hurt their pocketbooks. Turn up the fines, institute a mandatory 10 or 12 game suspension as the starting point for delivering a bean, eject the pitcher and the pitching coach. Make it hurt, like a beanball does. Or perhaps more managers could look to the late, great Earl Weaver, Baltimore Orioles Hall of Fame Manager on why the bean is a bad idea:

“It might lead to a fight. And if there’s a fight, our guys and their guys are going to get ejected, and our guys are better than their guys, so we’re going to lose on that exchange. So, don’t hit them!”

Blog Widget by LinkWithin

Comment Via Facebook


Powered by Facebook Comments

fold-left fold-right
About the author
Tom Brady and Craft Beer. She enjoys both of those for 17 weeks every Fall and it is a glorious time for her. Raised in sunny San Diego, she grew up a Chargers fan and a Packers fan because her Dad is from Wisconsin. After a move to BFE Ohio in 1992, she decided to switch allegiances and become a Patriots fan. Why? Well, the uniforms were pretty colors and she was 12. In college she became a Yankees fan out of spite and in her late 20's she became an LSU fan out of love. After moving to Pittsburgh in 2010, she's become a die-hard Pirates fan and a reluctant Penguins fan. Can someone teach her about hockey, please? She will never, ever, ever under any circumstances, root for the Steelers. Ever. Don't ask her about basketball or soccer or any other sports, she could care less.

Comment Via Facebook


Powered by Facebook Comments

6 Replies to The Beanball: A Scourge In Baseball

  1. norm says:

    I agree with your plan to increase punishment for the beanball but only if similar punishments are applied to the designated hitter.

  2. MsBossyNoPants says:

    Can you expand upon this a little bit? I’m not sure why we would punish the DH.

  3. “I think a better “punishment” for a bean is stronger discipline from the league.” – YES YES YES.

  4. norm says:

    I just hate the DH, that’s all 😉

  5. MsBossyNoPants says:

    I knew I liked you!

  6. MsBossyNoPants says:

    Well that’s fair I suppose, but I’m not sure how we can punish someone for being a hitter. :)

Comments are now closed for this article.