Okay, you’ve seen Part 1, which showed us what everyone already knows – that Tropicana Field sucks – and ranked the ballparks in the order I’d like to see them from #29 all the way up to #6. The list, again, doesn’t include Comerica Park, nor does it include wherever the Twins would play. An astute observer would’ve noticed that I listed Busch Stadium twice – at #16 and #13. Maybe it’s just that good, I don’t know. I think, however, that placing it at #13 was an error, and it’s rightful spot is between PNC Park and Nationals Park.
Which brings us to the top five. We’ve got two oldies, two newbies and the ballpark that laid the groundwork for almost all the ballparks that have followed it.
5. Citizen’s Bank Park – The home of the reigning two-time National League Pennant-winning Philadelphia Phillies, this park, to me, is downright beautiful. It has a two-tierred bullpen, three decks in right field and two decks in left. The lighted Liberty Bell and rooftop seating in centerfield that leaves no doubt about a Phillie home run. And finally, cheesesteaks in Ashburn Alley. Where do I sign up?
4. Miller Park – When this park first opened in 2001 I didn’t like it very much at all. It seemed like a big bowl and nothing more. However, as time went on, Miller Park grew on me. Bernie the Brewer still has his slide, although I’m pretty sure he doesn’t end up in a giant stein of beer like he did at County Stadium. There are enormous windows that give the park a massive, imposing presence. There are $1 seats with an obstructed view thanks to the mechanism of the incredible fanning roof. This, in my opinion, is how stadiums like this should be built.
3. Camden Yards – Can you believe this park has been open for 17 years? Yeah, me neither. I remember how everybody absolutely fell in love with Camden Yards when it first opened, with its classic style and charming atmosphere. The outfield with its asymmeetrical walls and high porch in right field combined with the use of the B&O Warehouse brings to life for me the days when ballparks were shoe-horned into city lots in any way possible. Camden Yards is the park that every new park since has tried to be and for that, I’ve placed Camden Yards at the top of the modern ballparks and third overall.
2. Wrigley Field – I have no doubt that Wrigley Field is a barn. Old Yankee Stadium was a barn, and I get the feeling that Wrigley would be the same, if not worse. That doesn’t take away any of my desire to see it, though. It’s 100 years of misery and goat stories and Steve Bartman and ivy on the walls and the epic manual scoreboard that calls my name. It’s Tiger Stadium again but alive and unique. It’s the place where Babe Ruth allegedly called his shot. I want to sit on a roof outside the park then go down to Waveland Avenue and fight for home run balls the day after I watch a game from inside the park. It’s 1060 West Addison – Elwood Blues’ published address with the Illinois DMV. Wrigley Field may be at the top of the vacation list for the summer of 2010.
And if you haven’t figured it out already, #1 with a bullet…

image courtesy of ballparksofbaseball.com
After visiting Yankee Stadium in the summer of 2008, there was no doubt that the next ballpark I’d like to cross of my list was Fenway Park. I knew why, but here, now, I don’t really know how to put my reasoning into words. While I thought about how I was going to describe what I love about Fenway, I got chills thinking of seeing the Green Monster, which is arguably the most recognizable feature of any stadium in sports. I imagined myself and 34,000 of my closest friends singing Sweet Caroline. Ted Williams played here. Johnny Pesky gave us the foul pole in right that let us all think we could hit a ball out of a major league ballpark. There’s not a day that goes by that I don’t want to be at Fenway Park. Even today, although it’s probably cold and rainy in Boston right now. Still, take me there.
So tell me, what’s your favorite?